Intertretation of teasing during early adolescence

  • 格式:pdf
  • 大小:90.67 KB
  • 文档页数:8

InterpretationofTeasingDuringEarlyAdolescence

AllisonKanterAgliata,StaceyTantleff-Dunn,

andKimberlyRenk

UniversityofCentralFlorida

Researchhassuggestedthatteasing,especiallyaboutphysicalappear-ance,isacommonexperiencewithnegativeconsequencesforadoles-cents.Thisstudyaimedtoexaminethecognitiveprocessesofadolescentsexposedtoteasing.Studentsfromtwomiddleschoolswereassignedrandomlytoviewvideotapedvignettesofappearance-relatedteasing,com-petencyteasing,oracontrolsituationandcompletedquestionnairestoassesstheircognitivereactionsandmemoriesoftheteasing.Resultsindi-catedthatadolescentgirlsrecalledappearance-relatedteasingmorereadilythancompetencyteasing,adolescentgirlswithhighbodydissatisfactionrecalledfewerpositiveappearancewords,andparticipantsexposedtocompetencyteasingweremorelikelytorecallcompetencywords.Thefindingsindicatedthatcognitiveprocessesmaybeimportantinthestudyofadolescents’interpretationofteasingandforclinicaltreatmentofado-lescentswhoareteased.©2006WileyPeriodicals,Inc.JClinPsychol63:23–30,2007.

Keywords:teasing;adolescents

Althoughadolescencehasbeenidentifiedasthetimewhenindividuals

aremostlikelyto

experiencehurtfulteasing(Shapiro,Baumeister,&Kessler,1991),surprisinglylittleempir-

icalliteraturehasemergedtofurthertheunderstandingofhowadolescentsperceive

teasinginteractionsorhowclinicianscanhelpadolescentscopemoreeffectivelywith

thesedifficultsituations(Shapiroetal.,1991).Studiesexaminingthecontentofteasing

amongyoungadolescentshavereportedthat66%ofteasingconsistsofname-calling,the

majorityofwhichfocusesonphysicalappearance,followedbycompetencyteasing

(Mooney,Creeser,&Blatchford,1991;Scambler,Harris,&Milich,1998;Shapiroetal.,

1991).Dependingonthepersonalityofthechildandhisorherdifferentinterpretationsof

theteasingsituation,teasingexperiencesmayaffectyoungadolescentsinvastlydifferent

ways(Scambleretal.,1998).

Thismanuscriptisbasedonamaster’sthesiscompletedbyAllisonKanterAgliataunderthesupervisionofStaceyTantleff-Dunn.Correspondenceconcerningthisarticleshouldbeaddressedto:AllisonKanterAgliata,UniversityofCentralFlorida,DepartmentofPsychology,P.O.Box161390,Orlando,FL32816;e-mail:AKanter104@aol.com

JOURNALOFCLINICALPSYCHOLOGY,Vol.63(1),23–30(2007)©2007WileyPeriodicals,Inc.PublishedonlineinWileyInterScience(www.interscience.wiley.com).DOI:10.1002/jclp.20302Cognitiveprocessesmayexplaindifferentreactionstoteasing.Basedonpersonal

experiencesandpsychologicalissues,anearlyadolescentmayattendtocertaininforma-

tionautomaticallyandunconsciously(Williamson,1996).Inreferencetoteasing,Scam-

blerandcolleagues(1998)showedthatteasinghistoryaffectswhatearlyadolescents

rememberfromteasinginteractions.Specifically,earlyadolescentswhohadagreater

historyofbeingteasedrememberedmoredetailsaboutspecificteasingincidentsthan

thosewhowereteasedlessoften.Thisbiasedprocessing,oruseofavailabilityheuristics,

maycreateagreaterpropensitytointerpretteasingasnegativebecauseindividualspay

attentiontoinformationthatismostreadilyavailableandrelevanttotheirownissues

(Kahneman&Tversky,1973).Ahistoryofteasingrelatedtoanindividual’spersonal

issuesmayhaveaverynegativeimpact(Thompson,1996).

Toaddressthelackofinformationregardingthetypesofadolescentsthatmaybe

mostsusceptibletoteasing,thisstudyexaminedtherelationshipsamongearlyadoles-

cents’characteristics,exposuretodifferenttypesofteasing,andmemoryforwordsrelated

toteasingcontent.Althoughtherealsohasbeenalackofresearchregardinggender

differencesinteasing,theliteraturesupportsthetendencyofindividualstobebiased

negativelytowardrelevantpersonalissues(Kahneman&Tversky,1973).Forexample,

adolescentgirlstendtohaveahigherprevalenceofeatingdisturbancedisorders(Lewin-

sohn,Seeley,Moerk,&Striegel-Moore,2002).Forthisreason,itwashypothesizedthat

thegenderofadolescentswouldberelatedtotheteasingtheyrecalled,withgirlsrecal-

lingmoreappearancethanacademiccompetenceteasingphrases.Itwasexpectedthat

adolescentswouldrecallmorecontentwordsrelatedtotheparticularteasingtheyviewed.

Italsowashypothesizedthatadolescentswithhigherbodydissatisfactionwouldrecall

morenegativeappearancewords.

Method

Participants

Students,whorangedfrom11to15yearsold,wererecruitedfromsixth,seventh,and

eighthgradesattwoschoolsinsuburbanneighborhoodsinaSoutheasternstate.One

schoolhadstudentsfromfamiliesthatwereofslightlyhighersocioeconomicstatus.Of

the350studentswhoweregivenaparentconsentform,202returnedtheformsigned.

Later,threegirlschosenottoparticipateinthestudy.Thus,thesampleincluded62

adolescentboysand137adolescentgirls.Theethnicityofthestudentswasasfollows:

75.0%Caucasian,12.5%Hispanic,4.4%AfricanAmerican,3.7%AsianAmerican,and

4.4%other.

MeasuresofParticipantCharacteristics

Onademographicsquestionnaire,studentparticipantswereaskedtoreporttheirsex,