给审稿人的模板
- 格式:doc
- 大小:45.00 KB
- 文档页数:1
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NONLINEAR SCIENCE (IJNS)
REFEREE’S REPORT
Reviewer: Prof. Date:
Ms. ID#: .
IJNS 20120409-zhigang
Paper Title:
Strong Convergence of Independent Fuzzy Variables Sequence
PAPER PROFILE
Please indicate X in the boxes which, in your opinion, best describe the following features of the manuscript.
Poor Marginal Acceptable Good Honours
Originality of the work
Scholarly relevance
Professional/industrial relevance
Completeness of the work
Acknowledgement of the work of others
by references
Organization of the manuscript
Clarity in writing, tables, graphs and
illustrations
RECOMMENDATION (please check appropriate boxes)
□
ACCEPT - with any possible minor changes, as stated overleaf
□
REVISE AND ACCEPT - subject to limited specific changes requiring a re-examination by the
Associate Editor only
□
REVISE AND RESUBMIT - May contain publishable results. Requires rewriting, resubmission, and
review of revised manuscript.
□
REJECT AND DO NOT ENCOURAGE RESUBMISSION
Paper is so poorly written that the contribution, if any, is obscure. □
Insufficient new material, see references listed in the review. □
Results are not correct, and there is no obvious way to correct them. □
Paper is not suitable for the Journal for reasons given in the review □
GRADING (please check appropriate box)
□
EXCELLENT
□
GOOD
□
AVERAGE
□
POOR
COMMENTS FOR EDITORIAL STAFF (These will not be sent to the author(s))
Ms. ID# .:
IJNS 20120409-zhigang
Ms. Title:
Strong Convergence of Independent Fuzzy Variables Sequence
Partical note: