给审稿人的模板

  • 格式:doc
  • 大小:45.00 KB
  • 文档页数:1

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NONLINEAR SCIENCE (IJNS)
REFEREE’S REPORT

Reviewer: Prof. Date:
Ms. ID#: .
IJNS 20120409-zhigang
Paper Title:
Strong Convergence of Independent Fuzzy Variables Sequence
PAPER PROFILE
Please indicate X in the boxes which, in your opinion, best describe the following features of the manuscript.
Poor Marginal Acceptable Good Honours

Originality of the work
Scholarly relevance
Professional/industrial relevance
Completeness of the work
Acknowledgement of the work of others
by references
Organization of the manuscript
Clarity in writing, tables, graphs and
illustrations

RECOMMENDATION (please check appropriate boxes)

ACCEPT - with any possible minor changes, as stated overleaf


REVISE AND ACCEPT - subject to limited specific changes requiring a re-examination by the

Associate Editor only

REVISE AND RESUBMIT - May contain publishable results. Requires rewriting, resubmission, and

review of revised manuscript.

REJECT AND DO NOT ENCOURAGE RESUBMISSION

Paper is so poorly written that the contribution, if any, is obscure. □
Insufficient new material, see references listed in the review. □
Results are not correct, and there is no obvious way to correct them. □
Paper is not suitable for the Journal for reasons given in the review □
GRADING (please check appropriate box)

EXCELLENT


GOOD


AVERAGE


POOR

COMMENTS FOR EDITORIAL STAFF (These will not be sent to the author(s))
Ms. ID# .:
IJNS 20120409-zhigang
Ms. Title:
Strong Convergence of Independent Fuzzy Variables Sequence
Partical note: