Electrochimica Acta 107 (2013) 66–70Contents lists available at ScienceDirectElectrochimicaActaj o u r n a l h o m e p a g e :w w w.e l s e v i e r.c o m /l o c a t e /e l e c t a c taOptically transparent counter electrode for dye-sensitized solar cells based on cobalt sulfide nanosheet arraysSheng-Yen Tai,Chia-Feng Chang,Wei-Chen Liu,Jen-Hung Liao,Jeng-Yu Lin ∗,1Department of Chemical Engineering,Tatung University,Taipei 104,Taiwana r t i c l ei n f oArticle history:Received 23January 2013Received in revised form 24May 2013Accepted 26May 2013Available online 18 June 2013Keywords:Dye-sensitized solar cell TransparentCounter electrode CoS nanosheeta b s t r a c tIn this study,a transparent counter electrode (CE)based on cobalt sulfide (CoS)nanosheet arrays (NSAs)was incorporated for the first time in dye-sensitized solar cells (DSCs).First,Co(OH)2NSAs were elec-trodeposited onto a fluorine-doped tin oxide glass substrate,and then conversed to CoS NSAs by soaking in a chemical bath.UV–vis spectrophotometry,cyclic voltammetry,electrochemical impedance spec-troscopy and Tafel polarization measurements indicate that the resultant CoS NSAs CE exhibited both high transmittance (>70%)at wavelength of 550nm and superior electrocatalytic activity for I 3−reduction to a conventional Pt CE.The DSC assembled with the CoS NSAs CE displayed an impressive photovoltaic conversion efficiency of 6.39%,which even surpassed the DSC using a Pt CE (6.06%).© 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.1.IntroductionDye-sensitized solar cells (DSCs)have been extensively con-sidered as environment-friendly,low-cost,easy-fabrication,and acceptable power conversion efficient photovoltaic devices [1].A typical DSC is composed of a dye-sensitized TiO 2as a photoan-ode,an electrolyte consisting of I −/I 3−redox couple,and a counter electrode (CE).The CE is bifunctional in collecting electrons from the external circuit and speeding up the reaction of I 3−reduction for dye regeneration.The conventional CE is made of the noble Pt deposited on a transparent conducting glass due to its excellent electrocatalytic activity and chemical stability.However,in view of its high cost and limited resource,seeking low-cost substitutes is of demand.The previous substantial efforts have been made to find low-cost substitutes for the expensive Pt CE,such as carbon materials [2–4]and conducting polymers [5–8].Recently,a variety of transition metal sulfides,such as CoS [9–13],NiS [13,14],MoS 2[15–17],and WS 2[15],have been extensively reported as efficient CE materials.Wang et al.[9]first reported an electrochemically deposited CoS CE prepared by a potentiostatic technique in an alkaline aqueous bath simply containing CoCl 2and thiourea,which was employed as the source of sulfur in the deposition bath for the co-deposition.In recent years,our group has focused on developing the electrodeposited-CoS CE prepared in a near neutral deposition∗Corresponding author.Tel.:+886225925252x2561-119;fax:+886225861939.E-mail addresses:jylin@.tw ,d923615@ (J.-Y.Lin).1ISE member.bath by using a potentiodynamic technique [10–12].We found that the potentiodynamic deposition mode can not only facilitate the formation of more CoS component within the deposit compared to the conventional potentiostatic deposition mode,but also make the deposit with the mesoporous morphology to increase its active surface area.However,in the aforementioned studies,the thiourea was still employed to serve as an additive for CoS electrodeposition.The uneven adsorption distribution of thiourea may influence the current distribution during electrodeposition,thus possibly result-ing in the non-uniform distribution in thickness,especially for the large-scale electrodeposition.In this current work,a transparent CoS nanosheet arrays (NSAs)CE was constructed by a facile two-step approach.The Co(OH)2NSAs were firstly grown on a fluorine-doped tin oxide (FTO)glass substrate via an electrodeposition method in a deposition bath without any additives and subsequently soaked in a chemical bath to be converted to CoS NSAs.The resultant transparent CoS NSAs CE showed an excellent electrocatalytic activity for I 3−reduction and an impressive cell efficiency of 6.39%was achieved for the DSC based on the CE.Additionally,the characteristic of its optical trans-parency is not only a substantial benefit of DSCs for certain practical applications,like roof panels,windows or various decorative facili-ties,but also is essential for the operations of metal-foil-supported plastic DSCs [18–20].2.Experimental2.1.Preparation of CEsPrior to the preparation of CEs,FTO glass substrates (NSG 13 sq −1)glass substrates were cleaned thoroughly in acetone,0013-4686/$–see front matter © 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved./10.1016/j.electacta.2013.05.149S.-Y.Tai et al./Electrochimica Acta 107 (2013) 66–7067deionized water and isopropanol for 10min,respectively.The elec-trodeposition of Co(OH)2NSAs was carried out in an aqueous deposition bath containing 5mM CoCl 2·6H 2O (Acros,99%)at ambi-ent atmosphere with a three-electrode system,in which a cleaned FTO substrate served as the working electrode,a Pt wire acted as a counter electrode and a saturated Ag/AgCl electrode was used as the reference electrode.A constant potential of −0.8V vs.Ag/AgCl was employed for the electrodeposition of Co(OH)2NSAs on a FTO substrate.The deposition duration was set for 10min.Then,the resulting Co(OH)2NSAs CE was rinsed with deionized water and dried by nitrogen gas.The CoS NSAs CE was further obtained by soaking the Co(OH)2NSAs CE into an aqueous solution containing 5mM Na 2S ·9H 2O at 60◦C for 1min.After that,the CoS NSAs CE was rinsed with deionized water and dried by the nitrogen gas again.2.2.Assembly of DSCsThe TiO 2photoanodes (0.28cm 2)were prepared by using screen-printing approach to print the bi-layer composed of a dense layer (∼12m,ETERDSC Ti 2105,Eternal Chemical Co.)and a scattering layer (∼2m,ETERDSC Ti 2325,Eternal Chemi-cal Co.)on the FTO glass substrates.The TiO 2photoanodes were further immersed in the 0.3mM N719dye (Everlight Chemical Industry Co.)for 12h in a room temperature after sintered at 450◦C for 30min.Then,the sensitized TiO 2photoanodes were assembled with CEs and sealed with hot-melt Surlyns (DuPont,30m)to make standard sandwich-type configuration.Finally,the DSCs were completely assembled after the redox electrolyte containing 1M 1,3-dimethylimidazolium iodide (Merck),0.5M 4-tert-butylpyridine (Aldrich),0.15M iodine (J.T.Baker),and 0.1M guanidine thiocyanate (Aldrich)in 3-methoxypropionitrile (Acros)was injected into the cells via the predrilled holes on the CEs.2.3.Characterizations and measurementsSurface morphology and composition of the deposits were char-acterized by a scanning electron microscopy (JSM-700F)equipped with an energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS)and an X-ray diffraction (XRD)spectrometer.The transmittance spectrum was recorded with an Agilent 8453UV-Visible diode array spec-trophotometer.The following electrochemical measurements were carried out using a CHI614d potentiostat.The cyclic voltammetry (CV)was performed in 3-methoxypropionitrile solution consisting of 50mM LiI,10mM I 2,and 50mM LiClO 4using a three-electrode system,in which the as-prepared CE served as the working elec-trode,in addition to a Pt sheet counter electrode and Pt wire reference electrode.The electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS)and Tafel polarization measurements were conducted usingFig.1.XRD patterns of the as-prepared deposits on FTO glass substrates before and after soaking in the 0.01M Na 2S aqueous solution.the symmetric configuration cells.EIS measurements were per-formed at the zero bias voltage within the frequency range explored from 50kHz to 0.1Hz;the corresponding ac amplitude was 5mV.The Nyquist plots were fitted by the software ZSimpWin version 3.1.The photovoltaic characteristics of DSCs were made by means of the solar simulator (Yamashita Denso YSS-150A,AM 1.5G)under the incident light intensity of 100mW cm −2,which was calibrated with a radiant power/energy meter (Oriel,70260).3.Results and discussionFig.1shows the XRD patterns of the as-prepared deposits on FTO glass substrates before and after soaking in the 0.01M Na 2S aque-ous solution.For the deposit without the post-treatment soaking,the resultant XRD diffusion peaks at around 32.4◦,57.8◦and 59.6◦can be indexed as the contribution from Co(OH)2(JCPDS#898616).However,the diffusion peaks were changed to 29.9◦,30.8◦,32.4◦,and 43.6◦,which can be assigned as the contribution of Co 9S 8(JCPDS#750605)after soaking in the Na 2S aqueous solution at 60◦C for 10min.This indicates that the main composition of the deposit was successfully changed from Co(OH)2to CoS.It is interesting that the surface morphology did not suffer any evolution during this conversion process,and thus the NSAs structure was still displayed for the CoS CE (Fig.2).The EDX element mapping for the Co(OH)2and CoS NSAs are also presented in Fig.2.Notably,no S element was found for the Co(OH)2NSAs;however,both Co and S elements wereFig.2.FESME images and EDS mappings of the as-prepared deposits on FTO glass substrates (a)before and (b)after soaking in the 0.01M Na 2S aqueous solution.68S.-Y.Tai et al./Electrochimica Acta 107 (2013) 66–70Table 1Photovoltaic parameters of the DSCs assembled with different CEs and electrochemical parameters from EIS and Tafel measurements.R s ( cm 2)R ct ( cm 2)C dl (F cm −2)J 0(mA cm −2)J sc (mA cm −2)V oc (V)FFÁ(%)Pt3.76 2.6111.56 2.2213.120.750.62 6.06Co(OH)2NSAs4.7762501.410.003 1.120.540.100.02CoS NSAs4.530.9544.412.9313.440.750.646.38detected and distributed uniformly for the CoS NSAs.This result confirms that Co(OH)2NSAs were successfully converted to CoS NSAs via the simple and facile chemical bath process,confirming the XRD results.Fig.3further shows the photograph and UV–vis transmittance spectrum of the CoS NSAs CE.The UV–vis transmit-tance spectrum demonstrates that the percentage transmittance for the CoS NSAs CE can reach over 70%in the wavelength region of 400–800nm,and that a transparent CoS NSAs CE can thus be fabricated.To understand the electrocatalytic activities of the aforemen-tioned CEs in the I −/I 3−redox system,CV tests were carried out.In the CVs,the corresponding redox reactions can be represented by Eqs.(1)and (2)[11,12].3I −→I 3−+2e −(anodic peak)(1)I 3−+2e −→3I −(cathodic peak)(2)Fig.4shows the CVs curves of Pt,Co(OH)2and CoS NSAs CEs.It is notable that there is no significant redox peaks observed for the Co(OH)2NSAs CE,suggesting that the Co(OH)2NSAs CE has poor electrocatalytic activity for I 3−reduction.However,when con-verted into the CoS NSAs CE,it possesses lower peak separation (E p )and higher cathodic current density (I pc )compared to the conven-tional Pt CE.The I pc corresponds to the speed for I 3−reduction.Additionally,the E p value depends not only on the rate of electron transfer,but also the porosity of electrode [21,22].The enhanced I pc value and the decreased E p value can be ascribed to its nanosheets structure,which can not only provides a larger active surface area for I 3−reduction,but also constructs lots of open channels for the diffusion of I −/I 3−redox species.Fig.5presents the photovoltaic characteristics of the DSCs based on the Pt,Co(OH)2and CoS NSAs CEs,which were measured under AM 1.5G simulated solar light (100mW cm −2).The photovoltaic parameters,which are averaged from the three different cells,are tabulated in Table 1.The DSC using the Pt CE exhibits ashort-circuitFig.3.Photograph and UV–vis transmittance spectrum of the transparent CoS NSAs CE.The photographs for a FTO glass substrate (left)and CoS NSAs CE (right)are presented in theinset.Fig.4.CVs for I −/I 3−redox system using Pt,Co(OH)2and CoS NSAs CEs at a scan rate of 10mV s −1.current density (J sc )of 13.12mA cm −2,open-circuit voltage (V oc )of 749mV,fill factor (FF )of 0.62,and photovoltaic conversion effi-ciency (Á)of 6.06%.Nevertheless,the DSC based on the Co(OH)2NSAs CE shows a much lower J sc (1.12mA cm −2),FF (0.10)and V oc (0.54),thus resulting in a low Áof 0.02%.This signifies its intrin-sically poor electrocatalytic activity for I 3−reduction,which is in well accordance with the CV results.When the Co(OH)2NSAs CE is soaked in the Na 2S solution,the converted CoS NSAs CE exhibits sig-nificantly improved J sc (13.44mA cm −2)and FF (0.64)values,which are even slightly higher than those of the DSC with the Pt CE,result-ing in a relatively higher Áof 6.39%compared to the DSC using the Pt CE.The enhanced photovoltaic performance demonstrates that the CoS NSAs can be considered as an impressive CE catalyst for I −/I 3−basedDSCs.Fig.5.Photovoltaic performances of the DSCs assembled with Pt,Co(OH)2and CoS NSAs CEs.S.-Y.Tai et al./Electrochimica Acta107 (2013) 66–7069Fig.6.(a)Nyquist plots of the symmetrical cells based on Pt,Co(OH)2and CoS NSAs CEs.The equivalent circuit model used to simulate the resultant spectra is shown in the inset.To get more insight to the electrocatalytic kinetics for the CEs, EIS and Tafel measurements were conducted using the symmetric cells fabricated with two identical CEs.Fig.6shows the EIS spectra for the Pt,Co(OH)2and CoS NSAs CEs.The resultant EIS spectra werefitted to the equivalent circuit model illustrated in the inset of Fig.6.The equivalent circuit model includes a Randles-type circuit consisting of a charge transfer resistance(R ct)and a parallel double-layer capacitance(C dl)plus a series resistance(R s)and the Nernst diffusion resistance(Z N).The detailed EIS parameters are also summarized in Table1.The R ct value for the CoS CE is merely0.95 cm2,lower than the value of the conventional Pt CE (2.61 cm2),confirming that the CoS NSAs CE possesses a rela-tively higher electrocatalytic activity for I3−reduction.The lower R ct value at the CE/electrolyte interface facilitates the electron transfer from the CE to the I3−species,thus resulting in a higher FF value[23,24].The enhanced FF value can be possibly ascribed to its high intrinsic electrocatalytic activity.In contract,the R ct value for the Co(OH)2NSAs CE is over6000 cm2,indicating a poor electrocatalytic activity that resulted in a low FF andÁvalues in the aforementioned photovoltaic performance.Moreover,the large C dl value(44.4F cm−2)of the CoS NSAs CE corresponds to its large active surface area originating from its nanosheets structure,which is in a good agreement with the observation in the CV tests.The increased active surface area could promote the electrocatalytic activity for I3−reduction and then increase the total current of the I−/I3−redox reaction,and thus an enhanced J sc value for the DSC with the CoS NSAs CE can be obtained[25,26].To elucidate the electrocatalytic behavior more accurately, Tafel-polarization measurements were further conducted using the aforementioned symmetric dummy cells.Fig.7shows the Tafel polarization curves for the Pt,Co(OH)2and CoS NSAs CEs.The curves present logarithmic current density as a function of poten-tial,which can provide information about the exchange current density(J0)as shown in Table1.The remarkable enhancement in the J0value is found when the Co(OH)2NSAs CE is converted to the CoS NSAs pared to the Pt CE,the CoS NSAs CE still displays a higher J0value,which is in a good agreement with the R ct values obtained from the EIS tests in terms of Eq.(3)[27].On the other hand,the intersection of the cathodic branch with the Y-axis can be regarded as the limiting current density(J lim).It can be observed that CoS NSAs CE has a larger J lim value than the Pt CE.On the basis of Eq.(4),J lim is positively related to the diffusion coefficient(D), which illustrates the diffusion behavior of the redox couple in the electrolyte.The estimated diffusion coefficient for the Pt CEand Fig.7.Tafel polarization curves of the I−/I3−symmetrical cells based on Pt,Co(OH)2 and CoS NSAs CEs.CoS NSAs CE is2.37×10−7cm2s−1and4.19×10−7cm2s−1,respec-tively.The improved D value for the CoS NSAs CE can be ascribed to its nanosheets structure,which can constructs lots of open channels for the redox species transport.J0=RTnFR ct(3) D=l2nFCJ lim(4) where R is the gas constant,T is the temperature,F is the Faraday constant,n is the number of electrons exchanged in the reaction at the CE/electrolyte interface,D is the diffusion coefficient of the I3−species,l means the spacer thickness,and C represents the concen-tration of I3−species.4.ConclusionsIn summary,a highly transparent CoS NSAs CE was successfully synthesized by simply electrodepositing Co(OH)2NSAs onto a FTO glass substrate and then soaking it in a chemical bath,and incorpo-rated for thefirst time in DSCs.The resultant CoS NSAs CE possessed both high transmittance(>70%)at wavelength of550nm and supe-rior electrocatalytic activity for I3−reduction to the conventional Pt CE.The DSC with the CoS NSAs CE showed an impressive pho-tovoltaic conversion efficiency of6.39%,which is even superior to that using the Pt CE(6.06%).The CoS NSAs CE can be prepared at low-temperature,which make it applicable toflexible substrates. Additionally,its highly transparent characteristic provides it with a promising potential for power-producing windows or TiO2/Ti foil-supported DSCs.AcknowledgementThis research was supported by National Science Council Taiwan under contacts NSC101-2221-E-036-035and NSC102-3113-P-110-004.References[1]M.Grätzel,Photoelectrochemical cells,Nature414(2001)338.[2]J.Chen,K.Li,Y.Luo,X.Guo,D.Li,M.Deng,S.Huang,Q.Meng,Aflexible carboncounter electrode for dye-sensitized solar cells,Carbon47(2009)2704.[3]K.Suzuki,M.Yamaguchi,M.Kumagai,S.Yanagida,Application of carbon nano-tubes to counter electrodes of dye-sensitized solar cells,Chemistry Letters23 (2003)28.70S.-Y.Tai et al./Electrochimica Acta107 (2013) 66–70[4]G.Wang,W.Xing,S.Zhuo,Application of mesoporous carbon to counter elec-trode for dye-sensitized solar cells,Journal of Power Sources194(2009)568.[5]J.G.Chen,H.Y.Wei,K.C.Ho,Using modified poly(3,4-ethylene dioxythiophene):poly(styrene sulfonate)film as a counter electrode in dye-sensitized solar cells, Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells91(2007)1472.[6]K.M.Lee,C.Y.Hsu,P.Y.Chen,M.Ikegami,T.Miyasaka,K.C.Ho,Highly porousPProDOT-Et2film as counter electrode for plastic dye-sensitized solar cells, Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics11(2009)3375.[7]Y.Xiao,J.Y.Lin,S.Y.Tai,S.W.Chou,G.Yue,J.Wu,Pulse electropoly-merization of high performance PEDOT/MWCNT counter electrodes for Pt-free dye-sensitized solar cells,Journal of Materials Chemistry22(2012) 19919.[8]R.Trevisan,M.Döbbelin,P.P.Boix,E.M.Barea,R.Tena-Zaera,I.More-Seró,J.Bisquert,PEDOT nanotube arrays as high performing counter electrodes for dye-sensitized solar cells.Study of the interactions among electrolytes and counter electrodes,Advanced Energy Materials1(2011)781.[9]M.Wang,A.M.Anghel,B.Marsan,N.C.Ha,N.Pootrakulchote,S.M.Zakeeruddin,M.Grätzel,CoS supersedes Pt as efficient electrocatalyst for triiodide reduc-tion in dye-sensitized solar cells,Journal of the American Chemical Society131 (2009)15976.[10]J.Y.Lin,J.H.Liao,T.C.Wei,Honeycomb-like CoS counter electrodes for trans-parent dye-sensitized solar cells,Electrochemical and Solid-State Letters14 (2011)D41.[11]J.Y.Lin,J.H.Liao,S.W.Chou,Cathodic electrodeposition of highly porous cobaltsulfide counter electrodes for dye-sensitized solar cells,Electrochimica Acta56 (2011)8818.[12]J.Y.Lin,J.H.Liao,Mesoporous electrodeposited-CoSfilm as a counter electrodecatalyst in dye-sensitized solar cells,Journal of the Electrochemical Society159 (2012)D65.[13]H.K.Mulmudi,S.K.Batabyal,M.Rao,R.R.Prabhakar,N.Mathews,m,S.G.Mhaisalkar,Solution processed transition metal sulfides:application as counter electrodes in dye sensitized solar cells(DSCs),Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics12(2011)19307.[14]H.Sun,D.Qin,S.Huang,X.Guo,D.Li,Y.Luo,Q.Meng,Dye-sensitized solar cellswith NiS counter electrodes electrodeposited by a potential reversal technique, Energy and Environmental Science4(2011)2630.[15]M.X.Wu,Y.D.Wang,X.Lin,N.Yu,L.Wang,L.Wang,A.Hagfeldt,T.L.Ma,Eco-nomical and effective sulfide catalysts for dye-sensitized solar cells as counter electrodes,Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics13(2011)19298.[16]C.J.Liu,S.Y.Tai,S.W.Chou,Y.C.Yu,K.D.Chang,F.S.S.Chien,J.Y.Lin,T.W.Lin,Facile synthesis of MoS2/graphene nanocomposite with high catalytic activity toward triiodide reduction in dye-sensitized solar cells,Journal of Materials Chemistry22(2012)21057.[17]S.Y.Tai,C.J.Liu,S.W.Chou,F.S.S.Chien,J.Y.Lin,T.W.Lin,Few-layer MoS2nanosheets coated onto multi-walled carbon nanotubes as a low-cost and highly electrocatalytic counter electrode for dye-sensitized solar cells,Journal of Materials Chemistry22(2012)24753.[18]Y.Xiao,J.Wu,G.Yue,J.Lin,M.Huang,L.Fan,n,Fabrication of high perfor-mance Pt/Ti counter electrodes on Ti mesh forflexible large-area dye-sensitized solar cells,Electrochimica Acta58(2011)621.[19]J.Wu,Y.Xiao,G.Yue,Q.Tang,J.Lin,M.Huang,Y.Huang,L.Fan,n,S.Yin,T.Sato,A large-area light-weight dye-sensitized solar cell based on all titanium substrates with an efficiency of6.69%outdoors,Advanced Materials24(2012) 1884.[20]J.Y.Lin, C.Y.Chan,S.W.Chou,Electrophoretic deposition of transparentMoS2/graphene nanosheet compositefilms as counter electrodes in dye-sensitized solar cells,Chemical Communications49(2013)1440.[21]J.G.Rowley,B.H.Farnum,S.Ardo,G.J.Mayer,Iodide chemistry in dye-sensitizedsolar cells:making and breaking I I bonds for solar energy conversion,Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters1(2010)3132.[22]J.H.Wu,Q.H.Li,n,P.J.Li,J.M.Lin,S.C.Hao,High-performance polypyrrolenanoparticles counter electrode for dye-sensitized solar cells,Journal of Power Sources181(2008)172.[23]T.Ma,X.Fang,M.Akiyama,K.Inoue,H.Noma,E.Abe,Properties of several typesof novel counter electrodes for dye-sensitized solar cells,Journal of Electroan-alytical Chemistry574(2004)77.[24]F.Fabregat-Santiago,J.Bisquert,E.Palomares,L.Otero,D.Kuang,S.M.Zakeerud-din,M.Grätzel,Correlation between photovoltaic performance and impedance spectroscopy of dye-sensitized solar cells based on ionic liquids,The Journal of Physical Chemistry C111(2007)6550.[25]K.Imoto,K.Takahashi,T.Yamaguchi,T.Komura,J.Nakamura,K.Murata,High-performance carbon counter electrode for dye-sensitized solar cells,Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells79(2003)459.[26]Q.H.Li,J.H.Wu,Q.W.Tang,n,P.J.Li,J.M.Lin,L.Q.Fan,Application ofmicroporous polyaniline counter electrode for dye-sensitized solar cells,Elec-trochemistry Communications10(2008)1299.[27]A.J.Bard,L.R.Faulkner,Electrochemical Methods:Fundamentals and Applica-tions,2nd ed.,Wiley,New York,2001.。