外研社英语辩论赛辩题外研社杯辩论赛辩题分析

1 外研社英语辩论赛辩题

外研社杯辩论赛辩题分析

THW require all healthy citizens to register their bone marrow data and donate marrow when needed. 正方Government 1.save people’s lives; 2. register their bone narrow can help doctor’s find the potential diseases of the citizens; 3. according to research, donating marrow brings no harm to donators’ health; 4.donating your marrow can help the doctor know the zygosity[zai‟ɡɔsəti, zi-] 配型 of your own marrow. Once you need the marrow from others, the success of zygosity can be improved, so your behavior in turn also benefit for yourselves. 反方opposition 1. Registering every healthy citizens bone marrow date may not protect

2 the privacy from intended information disclosure; 2. Local medical condition should be take into consideration. If the condition is bad, we can not promise that the donator’s health after donation. 3. We should fight against the monopoly of the marrow resources. If a single organization control all the resources of marrow, it can lead to corruption. THW grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing. 绝症患者应有权选择使用尚未完成临床测试检验的新药物或疗法。 正方（governments）: 1. At a point when all ordinary medical avenues have been expended, and the outcome appears bleak, new treatments still undergoing trials can be seen as the last

3 hope.It is almost impossible for those diagnosed with terminal illnesses recover from the diseases, so choosing treatments that have not completed clinical testing at least can give them opportunity to survive. people have the right to do as they please; including exposing themselves to risk, as long as in so doing they do not harm others (Mill’s harm principle).1Those diagnosed with 2. We live in a free society, and accept that terminal illnesses are responsible for their lives. As a patient, you can choose your doctor and treatment, so accessing treatments that have not completed clinical testing is one of the option for people who have free will. 3. Without the volunteers to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing, we cannot make progress in terms of medical development, and we cannot make sure these treatments are safe for human beings. So those diagnosed with terminal illnesses, if they choose to accept the treatment, whether success or not, they make contribution to our society. 4. Nowadays, many regulations have been made to protect the rights of the patients. For example, before you access treatments that have not completed clinical testing,

4 you should informed consent to treatment, all the privacy can not be leaked. If any sequelae happened after the treatment, the hospital is supposed to mitigate your medical fee without any contidition,you can even decide to quit during the treatment .So those diagnosed with terminal illnesses have nothing to worry about. 反方（opposition） 1. We have no idea that what kind of effects the treatments that have not completed clinical testing may bring to the patient, what if it caused severe paralysis? What if the patients turned into the zombie just as in American TV the walking dead? Thus, to allow such drugs and treatments to be handed out during the testing process, there is a great risk of giving people false hope. 2. Not all the patients diagnosed with terminal illnesses have rights to choose their treatments. Such as „dʒʊvənl, psychopath,they can not think reasonable, may be they don’t know how to chose anything. 3. This policy enhances the role of drug reps

5 and advertising, at the cost of evidence-based medicine. By allowing anyone who is critically ill to use experimental drugs you enhance the already dubious 可疑的role of drug company reps: there is already a problem of patterns of prescription being altered by the techniques of drug reps, rather than by evidence1 Where drugs are for sale before they have completed testing, there is even less evidence available, and therefore less ability for physicians to contest the claims of either reps or their own patients (who may have heard of the drug during their own research). Hence you magnify the problem of potentially ineffective of even harmful prescription 百度搜索“就爱阅读”,专业资料,生活学习,尽在就爱阅读网92to.com,您的在线图书馆