• Frege pointed out some problems for Reference Theory. • Unicorn, dragon, if, so, not • 启明星、长庚星 • 妻子,内人 • 具有心脏的动物,具有肾脏的动物 • Husserl: a>b, b<a • 词语与现实世界不是直接的关系,还有“系 统意义”(sense meaning) • Sense meaning 是在心理表征的层面,语 句和意义就是它所表达的思想或概念,这是 更为基本的意义,它是外指意义的基础。
1、指称论
• Reference Theory,Referential Theory, Referentialism, Naming Theory,Denotational Theory • Holders:1 Plato (427B.C. -347B.C) 2 Augustine (354-430) 3 J. S. Mill (1806-1873) 4 Wittgentein (pre-period, Picture Theory) 5 Russell, Peirce
• Key Points: • There is a direct relation between forms of language and those the relevant language forms refer to. • Meaning is the relation formed between language and what the language refers to. • Desk, Cup, Classroom, Teacher
• Locke • Words in their primary or immediate signification, stand for nothing, but the ideas in the mind of him that uses them. • Hume • Meanings as concepts: the ideational theory of meaning.