Spontaneous Emission Spectrum in Double Quantum Dot Devices

5TL?|@?iL t,4 tt L?5TiU|h 4 ?#L M*i" @?| 4#L|#i Uit Wrvklpdvd Ixmlvdzd4>5/Wmhun K1Rrvwhundps4/Zloiuhg J1ydq ghu Zlho4/Ehqqr Z1Eurhu4/Udp r q Djxdgr4/Vhljr Wduxfkd5>6dqg Ohr S1Nrxzhqkryhq41#iT@h|4i?|Lu TT* i_ )t Ut@?_#W ,5c#i*u|N? iht |)LuAiU ?L*L})c L DfeSc2Sff B #i*u|c A i i| ih*@?_t2 AA @t U+iti@hU w@MLh@|Lh itcc Lh ?Lt@|L `@!@4 )@c |t } c k@?@}@ @c2e f bHc a@T@?#iT@h|4i?|Lu )t Utc N? iht |)Lu AL!)Lc. OL?}Lc ?!)L ! cAL!)L ff c a@T@?Et M4 ||i_|L5U i?Uic a *)2 c bbH_L M*i^ @?| 4_L|_i Ui t@| ?@M*i| L *i i*t)t|i4uLh i*iU|hL? U i?ih})t|@|it _U i*iU|hL?U hhi?|_ hiU|*)4i@t hit| i h@|it uLh i*@t| U@?_ ?i*@t| U|h@?t | L?t Mi| ii?| i| L*i i*t6Lh ?i*@t| U|h@?t | L?t i?ih}) t i U @?}i_ | MLtL? U_i}hiit Lu uhii_L4 ?| i i? hL?4i?|A i ?i*@t| U|h@?t | L?h@|it@hi i**_itUh Mi_M)| i, ?t|i ?ULi U i?|tc hi*@| ?}@MtLhT| L?| t| 4 *@|i_@?_tTL?|@?iL t i4 tt L? A i4Lt|igiU| i*)UL T*i_MLtL?t ?| i tTiU Ui? hL?4i?|Lu L h ti4 UL?_ U|Lh_i Ui@hi@UL t| U T L?L?t A i i Tih 4i?|t_i4L?t|h@|i| i4TLh|@?Ui Lu @U 4 U| @| L?t ?| i i? hL?4i?|uLh* ||*i U hU |t Lu UL ihi?|^ @?| 4_i UitHohfwurqlf txdqwxp ghylfhv h{soruh txdqwxp phfkdq0 lfdo surshuwlhv ri hohfwurqv frq qhg wr vpdoo uhjlrqv lq d vrolg e|phdqv ri prghuq ideulfdwlrq whfkqltxhv1H{0 lvwlqj ghylfhv lqfoxgh vhplfrqgxfwru uhvrqdqw wxqqholqj glrghv+4,+edvhg rq txdqwxp phfkdqlfdo frq qhphqw,/ vxshufrqgxfwlqj Mrvhskvrq mxqfwlrq flufxlwv+5,+edvhg rq pdfurvfrslf skdvh frkhuhqfh,/phwdoolf vlqjoh hohf0 wurq wudqvlvwruv+6,+edvhg rq txdqwl}dwlrq ri fkdujh,/ dqg prohfxodu hohfwurqlf ghylfhv+7,1Wkh sulqflsoh ri rshudwlrq lq flufxlwv ri wkhvh ghylfhv lv edvhg rq frqwuro0 olqj hqhuj|vwdwhv/iru lqvwdqfh/e|phdqv ri dq h{whuqdo +jdwh,yrowdjh1Rqh vrxufh iru xqzdqwhg wudqvlwlrqv dqg huuruv lv dozd|v wkh wkhupdo hqhuj|iurp d qrq0}hur whp0 shudwxuh1Krzhyhu/hyhq dw}hur whpshudwxuh ydfxxp xfwxdwlrqv lq wkh hqylurqphqw fdq jlyh ulvh wr wudqvl0 wlrqv ehwzhhq vwdwhv ri qrq0htxdo hqhuj|e|vsrqwdqhrxv hplvvlrq ri dq hqhuj|txdqwxp1Vxfk lqhodvwlf wudqvl0 wlrqv fdxvh huuruv lq pdq|sursrvhg vfkhphv iru txdq0 wxp flufxlwv1Zh kdyh vwxglhg lqhodvwlf wudqvlwlrqv lq d ixoo|0frqwuroodeoh/wzr0ohyho txdqwxp v|vwhp uhdol}hg lq d grxeoh txdqwxp grw ghylfh1Zh fdq uhodwh wkh wudqvlwlrq udwhv lqyroylqj hplvvlrq wr devruswlrq udwhv e|wkh Hlq0 vwhlq frh flhqwv ryhu rxu ixoo hqhuj|dqg whpshudwxuh udqjh1Dw rxu orzhvw whpshudwxuh zh gluhfwo|phdvxuh wkh hqhuj|0ghshqghqw udwh iru vsrqwdqhrxv hplvvlrq1Lq rxu vshfl f vhplfrqgxfwru ghylfh wklv hqhuj|lv hplwwhg lqwr wkh hqylurqphqw iruphg e|dfrxvwlf skrqrqv1 Rxu grxeoh txdqwxp grw+Ilj14D,lv ideulfdwhg lq wkh wzr0glphqvlrqdo hohfwurq jdv+5GHJ,ri dq Do0 JdDv2JdDv vhplfrqgxfwru khwhurvwuxfwxuh+8,1Wkh vrxufh dqg gudlq duh odujh5GHJ uhjlrqv zklfk vhuyh dv ohdgv iru frqwdfwlqj fxuuhqw dqg yrowdjh zluhv1Wkh wzr grwv/O dqg U/duh vhsdudwhg iurp hdfk rwkhu dqg iurp wkh ohdgv/e|srwhqwldo eduulhuv lqgxfhg e|qhjd0 wlyh yrowdjhv dssolhg wr wkh wkuhh phwdoolf jdwhv1Wxq0 qholqj ehwzhhq wkh gl huhqw uhjlrqv lv vx flhqwo|vwurqjwr ghwhfw fxuuhqw/exw zhdn hqrxjk vxfk wkdw wkh qxp0 ehu ri hohfwurqv lq hdfk grw lv d zhoo0gh qhg lqwhjhu1 Wkh hqhuj|vwdwhv lq vxfk ixoo|frq qhg uhjlrqv duh glv0 fuhwh/3G0vwdwhv>uhvhpeolqj glvfuhwh dwrplf vwdwhv+9/:,1 Wkh glvfuhwh hqhujlhv lqfoxgh frqwulexwlrqv iurp vlqjoh0 hohfwurq fkdujlqj hqhujlhv/dulvlqj iurp Frxorpe lqwhudf0 wlrqv/dqg iurp txdqwxp0phfkdqlfdo frq qhphqw1Wkh orzhvw hqhuj|vwdwh iru rqh dgglwlrqdo hohfwurq lq wkh ohiw grw lv odehohg lq Ilj14E0G dv H O dqg vlploduo|H U iru wkh uljkw grw1Ilj14F looxvwudwhv wkh uhvrqdqfh frqglwlrq/ H O@H U/lq zklfk fdvh dq hohfwurq fdq wxqqho hodvwlfdoo| iurp dq rffxslhg vwdwh lq wkh vrxufh yld H O dqg H U wr dq hpsw|vwdwh lq wkh gudlq1Vxfk wxqqholqj vhtxhqfhv ri vlq0 joh hohfwurqv duh uhjxodwhg e|wkh Frxorpe fkdujlqj hq0 hujlhv+6/:,1Zkhq wkh wzr vwdwhv duh qrw doljqhg/H O@ H U/rqo|lqhodvwlf wudqvlwlrqv duh doorzhg iru zklfk vrph hqhuj|qhhgv wr eh h{fkdqjhg zlwk wkh hqylurqphqw1D phdvxuhg r 0uhvrqdqfh fxuuhqw/wkhuhiruh/gluhfwo|sur0 ylghv lqirupdwlrq derxw wkh frxsolqj ehwzhhq hohfwurqv rq wkh grwv wr ghjuhhv ri iuhhgrp lq wkh hqylurqphqw1 Wkh lqhodvwlf udwhv fdq eh dqdo|}hg zlwk zhoo0ghyhorshg phwkrgv lq txdqwxp rswlfv+;/<,1Iljxuh4H vkrzv d w|slfdo fxuuhqw vshfwuxp yhuvxv % H O H U dw rxu orzhvw odwwlfh whpshudwxuh W@ 56pN+43,1Wkh jdwh yrowdjhv Y JU dqg Y JO duh vzhsw vlpxowdqhrxvo|vxfk wkdw wkh uhvshfwlyh hqhujlhv duh olnh lq Ilj14E0G>wkdw lv/%@3rffxuv lq wkh plggoh eh0 wzhhq wkh Ihupl hqhujlhv ri vrxufh dqg gudlq/ V dqg G/dqg m%m@hY VG lv pd{lpdo fruuhvsrqgv wr kdylqj wkh vwdwhv H O dqg H U doljqhg wr rqh ri wkh Ihupl hq0 hujlhv1Wr dqdo|}h wkh odujh dv|pphwu|/zh ghfrpsrvh wkh wrwdo fxuuhqw L wrw+%,@L ho+%,.L lqho+%A3,lqwr d v|pphwulf sduw L ho+%,@L ho+ %,+gdvkhg fxuyh,dqg wkh uhpdlqlqj dv|pphwulf sduw L lqho+%A3,+grwwhg0gdvkhg fxuyh,1Dw W@3/L ho+%,lv gxh wr hodvwlf wxqqholqj dqg kdv d Oruhqw}ldq olqhvkdsh L ho+%,@L ho>pd{z5@+z5.%5,4+44,1Wkh ixoo zlgwk dw kdoi pd{lpxp+IZKP,/5z>fdq eh wxqhg e|wkh fhqwudo jdwh yrowdjh Y JF urxjko|iurp7 wr53 hY1Iurp phdvxuhphqwv ri L ho+%,dw srvlwlyh dqg qhjdwlyh Y VG lw lv srvvleoh wr h{wudfw ydoxhv iru wkh wxqqho frxsolqjv O/ U dqg W f+44/45,1Wkh uhpdlqlqj fxuuhqw/L lqho+%A3,>zklfk lv qrq0}hur rqo|iru%A3/lv gxh wr lqhodvwlf wxqqholqj1Lq Ilj14H/ L lqho lv qrq0}hur ryhu dq hqhuj|udqjh ri 433 hY>wklv ghvslwh wkdw wkh wkhupdo hqhuj|nW+56pN,@5 hY lv pxfk vpdoohu1+Wkh luuhjxodu qh vwuxfwxuh lv glvfxvvhg ehorz1,Lq jhqhudo zh qg wkdw L lqho ydqlvkhv zkhq rqh ri wkh ohyhov/H O ru H U/furvvhv rqh ri wkh wzr Ihupl hqhujlhv1Lq wkh vshfl f fdvh ri Ilj14H/H O dqg H U furvv wkh Ihupl hqhujlhv vlpxowdqhrxvo|/lpso|lqj wkdw L lqho lv fxw r dw%@hY VG1Ehorz wklv fxw r /wkh ydoxh ri L lqho zdv qrw lq xhqfhg e|wkh ydoxh ri Y VG +46,1Iru W@3/zh fdq zulwh wkh frqglwlrq iru d qrq0}hur lqhodvwlf fxuuhqw dv V A H O A H U A G@ V hY VG1 Wkh dprxqw ri lqhodvwlf fxuuhqw ghshqgv rq wkh wudqvlwlrq udwhv dv=L lqho+%,@h+ 4O. 4l+%,. 4U, 41Zkhq wkh lqhodvwlf udwh l+%,iurp H O wr H U lv pxfk vpdoohu wkdq wkh udwhv wkurxjk wkh rxwhu eduulhuv/wklv uhgxfhv wr L lqho+%,@h l+%,=Wkh h hfw ri d qrq0}hur whpshudwxuh rq wkh fxuuhqw lv vkrzq lq Ilj15D1D kljkhu whpshudwxuh W/hqkdqfhv L wrw rq erwk wkh hplvvlrq+%A3,dqg wkh devruswlrq +%?3,vlgh1Wkh devruswlrq vshfwuxp vkrzv dq h{sr0 qhqwldo whpshudwxuh ghshqghqfh/h%@nW+gdvkhg olqhv,iru devroxwh hqhujlhv odujhu wkdq wkh hodvwlf fxuuhqw phdvxuhg dw56pN/wkdw lv m%m A z=Wr dqdo|}h wkh whpshudwxuh ghshqghqfh/zh dvvxph ervrq vwdwlvwlfv iru wkh ghjuhhv ri iuhhgrp lq wkh hqyl0 urqphqw1Wkh dyhudjh rffxsdwlrq qxpehu k q l ri hqylurq0 phqwdo prghv dw hqhuj|%lv jlyhq e|wkh Ervh0Hlqvwhlq glvwulexwlrq ixqfwlrq=k q l@4@+h%@nW 4,1Wkh udwhv iru devruswlrq/Z d/dqg hplvvlrq/Z h/fdq eh h{suhvvhg yhu|jhqhudoo|e|Z d@E d dqg Z h@D.E h /zkhuh wkh Hlqvwhlq frh flhqwv vwdqg iru vsrqwdqhrxv hplvvlrq +D,/vwlpxodwhg hplvvlrq+E h,dqg devruswlrq+E d,/dqg lv wkh hqhuj|ghqvlw|+;,1Iurp wkh Hlqvwhlq uhodwlrqv/ E d@E h@D k q l@ +;,/zh rewdlq=l+%?3,@Z d+%,@k q l D+ %,+4,l+%A3,@Z h+%,@+k q l.4,D+%,Wr whvw zkhwkhu wkh lqhodvwlf fxuuhqw iroorzv hplvvlrq dqg devruswlrq vwdwlvwlfv/zh fdofxodwh wkh ixoo fxuuhqw vshfwuxp iurp Htv141Iluvw/zh rewdlq wkh vsrqwd0 qhrxv hplvvlrq udwh iurp D+%,@L lqho+%A3/W@56 pN,2h=Wkh wudfh dw56pN lv h hfwlyho|dw}hur whp0 shudwxuh iru%5 hY vlqfh wkhq k q l 41Wkh hplv0 vlrq fxuuhqw dw kljkhu whpshudwxuhv iroorzv iurp L lqho+% A3/W,@h+k q l.4,D+%,/zkhuhdv wkh devruswlrq fxu0 uhqw iroorzv iurp L lqho+%?3/W,@h k q l D+ %,=Wkh uhfrqvwuxfwhg fxuuhqw vshfwuxp lv vkrzq lq Ilj15E1 Wkh fhqwudo sduw ri wkh fxuyhv+m%m?43 hY,lv nhsw eodqn vlqfh Ht14grhv qrw lqfoxgh wkh W0ghshqghqfh ri L ho1Wkh fdofxodwhg fxuuhqw uhsurgxfhv wkh phdvxuhg fxuuhqw zhoo xs wr533pN1Hyhq wkh vpdoo vwhs0olnh ihd0 wxuh vhhq dw% 63 hY lv uh hfwhg e|d vkrxoghu0olnh ihdwxuh dw% 063 hY lq wkh phdvxuhg dqg lq wkh fdo0 fxodwhg devruswlrq vshfwud+lqglfdwhg e|duurzv,1Iru W A533pN wkh phdvxuhg fxuuhqw vljql fdqwo|h{fhhgv wkh fdofxodwhg fxuuhqw/zklfk lv suredeo|gxh wr wkhu0 pdoo|h{flwhg hohfwurqv+Ht14rqo|ghvfulehv wkh W0 ghshqghqfh ri wkh hqylurqphqw1Wkh wkhupdo h{flwd0 wlrqv lq wkh hohfwurq ohdgv duh qrw lqfoxghg1,Ixuwkhu frq updwlrq ri wkh dssolfdelolw|ri wkh Hlqvwhlq uhodwlrqv wr rxu txdqwxp grw v|vwhp iroorzv iurp wkh suhglfwlrq= ^L lqho+%A3, L lqho+%?3,`@hD+m%m,@^Z h Z d`@D@4/ zklfk lv ydolg lqghshqghqw ri whpshudwxuh1Ilj15F vkrzv d sorw ri wkh qrupdol}hg udwhv/Z d@D dqg Z h@D/ yhuvxv nW@m%m iru ydulrxv%dqg W xs wr533pN1Wkh phd0 vxuhg gdwd forvho|iroorz wkh suhglfwlrq^Z h Z h`@D@ 4>wkdw lv/wkh qrupdol}hg udwhv/Z d@D dqg Z h@D/gl hu e|rqh ryhu wkh whpshudwxuh udqjh W?533pN zlwkrxw wwlqj dq|sdudphwhu1Wkh lqhodvwlf udwh iru d wzr0ohyho v|vwhp frxsohg wr d ervrqlf hqylurqphqw dw W@3lv h{shfwhg wr kdyh d W f5ghshqghqfh+47/48,1Vwloo zlwkrxw lghqwli|lqj wkh ervrqlf hqylurqphqw/zh fdq whvw wklv ghshqghqfh rq wkh hodvwlf wxqqho frxsolqj W f ehwzhhq wkh wzr grwv1Iljxuh 6D vkrzv wkdw wkh lqhodvwlf fxuuhqw fohduo|lqfuhdvhv zlwk W f1Iru wkh odujhvw frxsolqj zh rewdlq d vdwxudwlrq zkhuh wkh hodvwlf fxuuhqw shdn fdq qr orqjhu eh glvwlqjxlvkhg1 E| wwlqj wkh hodvwlf fxuuhqw sduw wr d Oruhqw}ldq olqh0 vkdsh+44,zh fdq rewdlq urxjk hvwlpdwhv iru W f dv orqj dv wkh fxuuhqw lv ohvv wkdq wkh vdwxudwlrq ydoxh1Zh qg wkdw zlwk wkhvh wwhg ydoxhv/wkh lqhodvwlf fxuuhqw vfdohv dv W f zlwk dq h{srqhqw @518 6/pd|eh vrphzkdw odujhu wkdq h{shfwhg1Iljxuh6E vkrzv wkh h hfw ri wkh lqfuhdvhg frxsolqj rq wkh v|pphwulf sduw ri wkh fxuuhqw dw orz whpshudwxuh1Iru vpdoo wxqqho frxsolqj/zh dozd|v rewdlq Oruhqw}ldq olqhvkdshv1Iru lqfuhdvlqj frxsolqjv/ wkh gdwd vwloo wv wr d Oruhqw}ldq wdlo rq wkh devruswlrq vlgh1Krzhyhu/zh jhqhudoo| qg vljql fdqw ghyldwlrqv iru vpdoo%/lpso|lqj wkdw iru odujh frxsolqj wkh hodvwlf dqg lqhodvwlf udwhv fdq ehfrph ri wkh vdph rughu1Wklv pd|irup d vljql fdqw olplwdwlrq iru wkh frkhuhqfh wlph lq frxsohg txdqwxp ghylfhv+49,1Wkh lpsruwdqfh ri xfwxdwlrqv lq wkh hqylurqphqw rq hohfwurq wxqqholqj wkurxjk txdqwxp ghylfhv kdv ehhq uhfrjql}hg iru d orqj wlph1Hqylurqphqwdo vwxglhv rq Frxorpe eorfndgh ghylfhv kdyh rqo|glvfxvvhg h hfwv gxh wr devruswlrq+6,1Iru hplvvlrq lw lv uhtxluhg wkdw hohf0 wurqv duh uvw sxpshg wr d kljkhu hqhuj|vwdwh1Wklv kdv uhfhqwo|ehhq grqh lq d vxshufrqgxfwlqj Frrshu sdlu wudqvlvwru xqghu plfurzdyh luudgldwlrq+4:,1Lq wkh fdvh ri d grxeoh grw/sxpslqj rffxuv zkhq H O A H U dqg dq hohfwurq wxqqhov lq iurp wkh ohiw uhvhuyrlu wr H O1D grxeoh grw wkxv r huv d xqltxh wzr0ohyho v|vwhp wkdw lv sxpshg e|d gf yrowdjh zlwkrxw lqgxflqj khdwlqj fxuuhqwv1Lw lvwkhuhiruh srvvleoh wr uhdfk dq rxw0ri0htxloleulxp vlwxd0 wlrq vr forvh wr W@3wkdw ydfxxp xfwxdwlrqv ehfrph wkh pdlq vrxufh iru jhqhudwlqj hohfwurq wudqvsruw1Wr lghqwli|zkhwkhu skrwrqv/sodvprqv/ru skrqrqv irup wkh ervrqlf hqylurqphqw/zh phdvxuhg vsrqwdqhrxv hplvvlrq vshfwud zkloh sodflqj wkh grxeoh grw lq gl huhqw hohfwurpdjqhwlf hqylurqphqwv1Lq wkh uhjlph430433 hY/ wkh w|slfdo zdyhohqjwkv duh4043fp iru skrwrqv dqg316 wr63fp iru5GHJ sodvprqv1Zh kdyh whvwhg wkh frx0 solqj wr wkh skrwrqlf hqylurqphqw e|sodflqj wkh vdpsoh lq plfurzdyh fdylwlhv ri gl huhqw vl}h+4;,1Wr fkhfn wkh frxsolqj wr sodvprqv/zh kdyh phdvxuhg gl huhqw w|shv ri ghylfhv zlwk odujho|gl huhqw glphqvlrqv ri wkh5GHJ ohdgv/jdwh sdgv/dqg erqglqj zluhv1Erwk w|shv ri ydul0 dwlrq kdg qr h hfw dw doo rq wkh hplvvlrq vshfwud>hyhq wkh qhvwuxfwxuh zdv uhsurgxfhg1Wkh wklug rswlrq ri dfrxvwlf skrqrqv lv wkh prvw olnho| srvvlelolw|+4<,1Skrqrq hplvvlrq udwhv kdyh ehhq fdofx0 odwhg iru vlqjoh grwv+53,1Iru d grxeoh grw v|vwhp/zh fdq rewdlq wkh jhqhudo hqhuj|ghshqghqfh+48,1Iru d gh0 irupdwlrq srwhqwldo zh h{shfw d udwh ghshqghqfh ri%G 5 +%iru6G skrqrqv dqg frqvwdqw iru5G skrqrqv,dqg iru slh}r0hohfwulf lqwhudfwlrq ri%G 7+4@%iru6G skrqrqv dqg4@%5iru5G vxuidfh dfrxvwlf zdyhv,+54,1Lq Ilj1 6F zh frpsduh wudfhv phdvxuhg rq wzr gl huhqw w|shv ri ghylfhv1Khuh/wkh hplvvlrq fxuuhqw lv sorwwhg yhuvxv%rq d orj0orj vfdoh1Ljqrulqj wkh expsv/zh qg dq hqhuj| ghshqghqfh ehwzhhq4@%dqg4@%51Wklv lpsolhv wkdw wkh grplqdqw hplvvlrq phfkdqlvp lv wkh slh}r0hohfwulf lqwhu0 dfwlrq zlwk5G ru6G dfrxvwlf skrqrqv1Qrwh wkdw d 4@%ru4@%5ghshqghqfh vkrxog eh dyrlghg lq frkhuhqw ghylfhv/vlqfh wkh lqhodvwlf udwh ehfrphv odujh qhdu uhvr0 qdqfh+% 3,+49,1Wkh expsv revhuyhg lq erwk w|sh ri ghylfhv vxjjhvw wkh h{lvwhqfh ri uhvrqdqfhv/iru lqvwdqfh/gxh wr d 0 qlwh vl}h lq wkh skrqrq hqylurqphqw1Wkh expsv duh sduwlfxoduo|fohdu lq wkh ghulydwlyh ri wkh fxuuhqw wr hq0 huj|+grwwhg fxuyhv lq Ilj16D,1Wkh odujh exps lq Ilj16D dw%@63 hY fruuhvsrqgv wr d iuhtxhqf|ri i@%@k@:16JK}1Iru6G skrqrqv wklv|lhogv d zdyh0 ohqjwk 6G@v6G@i@973qp+v6G@7;33p2v lv wkh6G vrxqg yhorflw|,/zkhuhdv iru5G vxuidfh dfrxvwlf zdyhv 5G@v5G@i@6;3qp+v5G@5;33p2v,1Wkhvh zdyh0 ohqjwkv erwk/pruh ru ohvv/ w zlwk wkh glphqvlrqv ri wkh wzr txdqwxp grw ghylfhv1Zh kdyh qrw|hw ehhq deoh wr frqwuro wkhvh uhvrqdqfh e|vwxg|lqj ghylfhv zlwk d yd0 ulhw|ri jdwh glphqvlrqv1Krzhyhu/zh eholhyh wkdw lw lv srvvleoh wr jdlq frqwuro ryhu wkh skrqrq hqylurqphqw e| pdnlqj6G skrqrq fdylwlhv lq kdqjlqj eulgjhv+55,ru e|fuhdwlqj d5G skrqrq edqgjds xvlqj d shulrglf jdwh jhrphwu|+56,1d o O 3 |@@?_A A@?L ic A i )t Ut@?_ TT* U@| L?tLu+itL?@?|A ??i** ?}# L_it E @4Mh _}i N? hittc @4Mh }id2o A i i 5 TihUL?_ U| ?},*iU|hL? Ut c hLUii_ ?}t Lu@A _ @?Ui_5| _)W?t| | |ic O `i ?t|LU!@?_+ `+@*t|L?,_t Ek* ihc#Lh_hiU |c bb2 c tih ,c L* 2D d o5 ?}*i @h}i A ??i* ?}c O Bh@Mih|@?_ O #i Lhi|c,_t c E *i? 4 hittc i vLh!c bb2 5ih c L* 2be deo w U, i?c @| hi c b c D E bbH (5 a A@?tc + VihtU ihi?c@?_ #i!!ihc @| hi c b c eb E bbH dDo A 6 t@ @@?_5 A@h U @c5 Tih*@|| Uit@?_ UhLt|h U| hit2 c2e.E bb. (aT? a TT* )t S c efff E bb.dSo5ii uLh hiUi?|TLT *@h hi i tG+ t LLh c @| hi .b ce E bbS (w kL i? L i?@?_ @hU tc)t Ut`Lh*_c TT D b Ea ?i bbHd.o6Lh@hi i c tii w kL i? L i?i|@* c ? itLULT U,*iU|hL?Ah@?tTLh|c hLUii_ ?}t Lu@ A _ @?Ui_5| _)W?t| | |i c w w 5L ?c w kL i?L i?c@?_B 5U L?c,_t c Ek* ihc#Lh_hiU |c bb. c tih ,c L* eDc TT fD 2 e(@ @ *@M*i L?* ?i@| ||TG%% Lh|i |? | _i*u| ?*% *iL!%T@Tiht%dHo ` *L?? c A i" @?| 4V@U 4c@?W?|hL_ U| L?|L^ @?| 4i*iU|hL_)?@4 Ut E U@_i4 U hittc5@?# i}Lc bbedbo A i t|@| t| Ut Lu L h ?i*@t| U i4 tt L?t L *_Mi hi} *@|i_M)| i t|@| t| Ut Lu t ?}*i i*iU|hL?| ??i* ?}c tii W4@4L}* @?_v v@4@4L|Lc )t +i eS c DbH2E bb2d fo A i t@4T*i @t ULL*i_ ?@_ * | L?hiuh }ih@|Lh | @*L it||i4Tih@| hi Lu2 4k # i|L?L ti| i igiU | i i*iU|hL?|i4Tih@| hi t;Df4k ?| i*i@_t W?@** 4i@t hi4i?|t i@TT*)@TihTi?_ U *@h4@}?i| U i*_ Mi| ii? S@?_2 e A|L4@ 4 3i| i t ?}*i T@h| U*i tT@U ?}t U | @| i U@??i}*iU||h@?tTLh|| hL } i U |i_t|@|itd o A i i*@t| U U hhi?| t} i?M)| i uLh4 *@U e,@r| S E0 'eA2S K-*d A2S E2n K-*K u n K2-*e n E0* 2oc tii v V @3@hL c )t U@ Hb c D.E bb (A O 5|LLu@?_v V @3@hL c )t +i D c fDf E bbSd 2o @?_ih V@@h|c i|@* c )t +i wi|| .e c e.f2E bbDd o *tL UL | ??i* ?}U@?} i i Uitt U hhi?|uLh0'f W?L h4i@t hi4i?|tc L i ihc| i UL | ??i* ?}U hhi?| t *itt| @?f f T @?_U@?Mi?i}*iU|i_ 6Lh@hi i L?UL | ??i* ?}tii# V ih ?@?_v V @3@hL c ?+iu c TT 2 . 2e.d eo a wi}}i|c i|@* c+i L_ )t c Db c E bH.d Do A2S _iTi?_i?Ui U@?@*tL Mi LM|@ ?i_uhL4Tih| hM@| L?| iLh) i?A S J0c tii w W B*@34@?@?_k @| ii c5L )t a,A S.c 2.S E bHHd So`i @ i hiTLh|i_@UL ihi?|UL T* ?}igiU| ?_L M*i^ @?| 4_L|t t ?}T L|L? @tt t|i_| ??i* ?}i Tih 4i?|tc ?A O Lt|ih!@4T i|@* c@UUiT|i_uLh T M* U@ | L? ? @| hi A iti LMtih @| L?t@hi4@_i i?@t4@** M @t L*|@}i t@TT* i_ W?| t U@ti i4 tt L?ThLUittit_L ?L|} i h ti|L U hhi?|d .o v @!@4 h@c # i?c@?_a 5 At@ c )t +iwi|| .b c2 2H E bb.d Ho`i ti_@U)* ?_h U@*U@ |)E S44 f He44 U@t@4 ? 4 4hitL?@?Ui i?ih})Lu@ML |2f>iVc@?_@hiU|@?} *@h U@ |)E22f b f H44 | hitL?@?Ui uhi^ i?U)Lu@ML |ef>iVd bo L T* ?}|L LT| U@*T L?L?t t i U i?|L?*)@|4 U*@h}ih i?ih} itd2fo N LU!i*4@??c )t +i Df c .2. E bbed2 o6Lh T L?L?t| i ?i*@t| U h@|i@|A'f U@?Mi h ||i?@t K ;E A S*0 2a E0*| ihi a E0 ;S#E0 0}E0 t| i tTiU|h@* u ?U| L?E e A i T L?L?_i?t |)Lu t|@|it}E0 ;0(! c t U | @|K ;A S2S2E0 0(!e ` i? i?i}*iU|TLtt M*i ?i t| U| hi ?S E0 c i @ i uLh_iuLh4@| L?TL|i?| @* S;0@?_| t K ;0(!2c *i uLh T i3L i*iU|h U ?|ih @U| L?S;UL?t|@?|@?_| t K ;0(!ed22o *i*@?_@?_ w +L !itc @| hi c b2c Sf E bbH d2 o a 5 *|L?c i|@* c a )t G L?_ 4@||ih H c wDE bb.d2eo`i| @?! #i Lhi|c w B*@34@?c5 BL_ ?c v O h@)@4@c a LL c v @3@hL c v AL ! h@c Nit } c N *i?hiiuc@?_ @?_ih V@@h|uLh i*T@?__ tU t t L?t 5 TTLh|i_M)| i# |U 6L ?_@| L?uLh6 ?_@ 4i?|@*+iti@hU L? @||ih E6 c w k M)| i+L)@* i| ih*@?_t U@_i4)Lu h|t@?_5U i?Uit6WB E #L M*i^ @?| 4_L|_i Ui_i ?i_ ?| i 2#,B Lu@B@ t% *B@ t i|ihL t|h U| hi M)uLU ti_ L? Mi@4 4T*@?|@| L? A i?@hhL U @??i*UL??iU|t| i*@h}i 2#tL hUi@?__h@ ?*i@_t i}@| i L*|@}it E T Cu c T C c@?_ T C- @TT* i_|L| i4i|@*}@|it E C u c C c@?_C-( _| t@hi ef?4 ?_ Ui| hii| ?@M*i| ??i*M@hh iht ?| i hi A i | L^ @?| 4_L|tc u@?_-c hitTiU| i*)c UL?|@ ?; D@?_ ;2D i*iU|hL?t(U @h} ?}i?ih} it@hi;e@?_; 4iV(@?_ | i4i@t hi_@ ih@}i tT@U ?}Mi| ii?t ?}*i T@h| U*i t|@|it @hi;f D@?_;f 2D4iV E c c@?_# ,?ih})_ @}h@4t E ih| U@*@ t @*L?}| i tT@| @*@ t| hL } | i_L|t E Lh 3L?|@*@ t uLh| i| ??i*t | @| L?tG@MtLhT| L?c i*@t| U@?_ i4 tt L? A U! ih| U@** ?it_i?L|i| ??i*M@hh iht A i UL?| ? L t i*iU|hL?t|@|it ?| i*i@_t@hi **i_ T|L| i 6ih4 i?ih} it>7@?_>( A i i |ih?@* L*|@}i T r_Mi| ii? *i@_t LTi?t@|h@?tTLh| ?_L Lu t 3iG eT r_'>73>( A i i?ih})c0 .u3.-c t_i ?i_@t| i_ gihi?Ui Mi| ii? | i|LT4Lt| **i__ tUhi|i t|@|i Lu| i*iu|_L|c.u c@?_| i *L it|_ tUhi|i t|@|i uLh@__ ?}@?i |h@i*iU|hL?|L| i h } | _L|c.- EA i ?|ih _L|U@T@U |@?Ui Thi i?|t| @|.u@?_ .-@hi t 4 *|@?iL t*)LUU T i_ ?i*@t| U U hhi?|U@? L i?0'fc L| ih ti@?L? 3ihL U hhi?|hi^ hit@MtLhT| L? E0 f Lh i4 tt L?Lu i?ih})E0:f A S t| i| ??i*UL T* ?}@?_K t| i ?i*@t| U h@|i Mi| ii?| i| L_L|t K u @?_K-@hi| i| ??i*h@|it@UhLtt| i*iu|@?_| i h } |M@h h iht E, A)T U@*4i@t hi4i?|Lu| i U hhi?|EtL* _ iht t0 @|2 4k A i4i@t hi_U hhi?| t_iUL4TLti_ ?@?i*@t| U E_@t i_ @?_@? ?i*@t| U E_L||i_ _@t i_ T@h|6WB 2 E i@t hi_U hhi?| iht t0uLh A'2 |L ff 4k A i U hhi?| t4i@t hi_uLh eT7(' ef>iV *i t iiT ?}T C-@?_T Cu t 4 *|@?iL t*) ?LTTLt |i_ hiU| L?t t U | @| i U @?}i| i i?ih})_ gihi?Ui0 B@|i L*|@}i t |h@?t*@|i_|L i?ih})0M)@U@* Mh@| L?Mi||ih| @? fI t ?} T L|L? @tt t|i_| ??i* ?}4i@t hi4i?|t E S #@t i_* ?it ?_ U@|i i TL?i?| @*_iTi?_i?Uic i0*&A c uLh 0 q&A h hL t TL ?|@|t|iT * !i t|h U| hi L?| i i4 tt L?t _i E0:f @?_@t L *_ih L?| i@MtLhT| L?t _i E0 f 6hL4 |t E |L| i i*@t| U U hhi?|T@h|@|2 4k i LM|@ ? K u E A S E >iV@?_ K-E f >iV uLh| t_@|@ti| E +iUL?t|h U|i_ U hhi?|uLh_ gihi?|A A i tTL?|@?iL t i4 tt L?tTiU|h 4 _ih i_uhL4| i4i@t hi__@|@@|2 4k@?_,^t @hi ti_|L hiUL?t|h U|| i u **|i4Tih@| hi@?_i?ih})_iTi? _i?Ui E A i@MtLhT| L?h@|i`@ELTi?t)4ML*t @?_i4 t t L?h@|i`e EU*Lti_t)4ML*t ?Lh4@* 3i_M)| i tTL?|@?iL t i4 tt L?h@|i iht t&A* 0 hU*itc t^ @hitc TTih @?_ *L ih |h @?}*itc@?__ @4L?_t@hi|@!i?@| 0 ' Hc2ec efc Sfc @?_Hf>iVc hitTiU| i*)Etii@*tL t)4ML*t ? A i tL* _ * ?i ?_ U@|it| i Lti , ?t|i ?_ t|h M | L?c'? c ihi@t| i _@t i_* ?i t L t'? n6WB hhi?|tTiU|h 4uLh_ gihi?|UL T* ?}i?ih} it@| 2 4k E A i4@}?i| U i*_ t S A uLh E @?_2 e A uLh | i L| ih U h it E f A i U h it @ i@?Lgti|c@?_U h i E t4 *| T* i_M)D +L } it| 4@|it uLh| i UL T* ?}i?ih} it @hiG E A S E;f >iV J K-E; f>iV c E A S E; >iV E K-E; >iV c E A S: K-E;f >iV c@?_ E A S q K-E;f f >iV @?_K u z K-uLh@**U h it A i| L_L||i_U h it@hi| i_ih @| it3_U*_0 ?@hM |h@h) ? |t uLh U h it E @?_E |L i? @?Ui| i M 4T t|h U| hi E wL}@h | 4 U * ?i@h T*L|t uLh E @?_E #@t i_* ?it @hi wLhi?|3 @? |t 6Lh E i U Lti T@h@4i|iht| @| || i |@ *uLh?i}@| i0 E wL}@h | 4 U *L}@h | 4 U T*L|t Lu| i i4 tt L?tTiU|h 4uLh| L_ gihi?|t@4T*it A i tL*_* ?it @hi|@!i?L?| i6W t@4T*i ?6 } E TTih|h@Ui t| i t@4i@t E ? (*L ih|h@Ui t uLh UL T* ?}i?ih} it Mi| ii?E @?_E ? A i_L||i_* ?i t|@!i?L?@t hu@Ui}@|i t@4T*i | @_ t|@?Ui Mi| ii?*iu|@?_h } |M@hh iht Lu Sff ?4E 2 A i_@t i_* ?it ?_ U@|i@ *0@?_ *02_iTi? _i?Ui i TiU|i_uLh T i3L i*iU|h U ?|ih@U| L? | #@?_2# T L?L?tc hitTiU| i*)E LµSµDE RΓLabsorptionΓRBΤcG LL R160220nmG C G RACE L E RelasticDE LE Remission-100100200ε (µeV)21I totI elI inelEeV SDFig. 1Fig. 3Fig. 2。