Responses-to-comments-(英文期刊-审稿意见回复)
Dear Editor-in-Chief in XXXXXXX:
Thank you very much for your help in processing the review of our manuscript (Manuscript ID XXXXX). We have carefully read the thoughtful comments from you and reviewers and found that these suggestions are helpful for us to improve our manuscript. On the basis of the enlightening questions and helpful advices, we have now completed the revision of our manuscript. The itemized responses to the reviewers’ comments are listed in the su cceeding sheets. We hope that all these corrections and revisions would be satisfactory. Thanks a lot, again.
1.Title: XXX
2.Manuscript type: Article
3.Corresponding author: XXX
4.Full author names: XXX
Sincerely,
Prof. XXX
School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering,
XX Key Laboratory of Controllable Chemistry
Reaction & Material Chemical Engineering,
XX University,
Wuhan, Hubei, 430072 , P R China.
2015-03-05
Responses to comments of Editor
Thank you for your serious and constructive comments on our manuscript. According to your suggestion, the manuscript has been revised as a letter to editor. The revisions we have made are as follows:
➢ 1 Subtitles "5. Conclusions", "6. Acknowledgments", and "7. References" should be revised into "4. Conclusions", "Acknowledgments", and "References", respectively.
Reply:
Thank you for your constructive and helpful suggestion.
The relevant subtitles have been revised in the revision.
➢2 In the section of the References, title of cited paper should be removed, and in ref.35 the superfluous comma should be deleted.
Reply:
Thank you for your constructive and helpful suggestion.
All the titles have been removed as you required and the superfluous comma in ref.35 has also been deleted.
➢ 3 Numerous relevant papers have been published in recent years especially in 2014 and 2015. Some key, important or/and latest research results in this field, should be mentioned and cited in the section of introduction instead of outdated or earlier papers so that we can provide a solid background and progress to the readers regarding the current state-of-knowledge on this topic. Therefore, I strongly require you to rewrite this part and then update your citations.
Reply:
Thank you for your constructive and helpful suggestion.
We have rewritten the section of introduction and updated corresponding citations as you required. In detail, some recent and excellent researches have been cited in the revision to replace those of
