3Ecclesine, Peter Disapprove General1 1.110 4Kennedy, Richard Disapprove General1 1.110 5Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical1 1.110
6Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial1 1.321
7Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical3 1.31 8Ecclesine, Peter Disapprove Technical3 1.32
9Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical422 10Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical4242 11Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical4250 12Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical521
13Struik, Rene Disapprove Editorial5244 14Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical7 3.2839
15Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical9 3.491
16Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial9 3.6538 17Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial124? 18Chouinard, Gerald Approve Technical1341
19Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Editorial1341 20Kennedy, Richard Disapprove Editorial134
21Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical1451 22Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial14 5.232 23Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical16 5.21 24Riegel, Maximilian Disapprove Technical16 5.420
25Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical16 5.420 26Riegel, Maximilian Disapprove General17 5.4.28 27Riegel, Maximilian Disapprove Technical18 6.236 28A, Antony Franklin Approve Editorial19 6.23
29Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical19 6.211 30A, Antony Franklin Approve Editorial20 6.2.124 31Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical21 6.2.230 32Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical21 6.2.3.147
33Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Editorial22 6.2.3.343 34A, Antony Franklin Approve Editorial23 6.316
35Freedman, Avraham Approve Editorial25 6.419 36Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial25 6.419 37Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial25 6.420 38Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial25 6.428
39Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical26 6.44 40Freedman, Avraham Approve Editorial28 6.623 41A, Antony Franklin Approve Editorial28 6.623
42Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial28 6.623
43Freedman, Avraham Approve Technical28 6.625 44Brethour, Vern Approve Editorial29
45Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical30 6.624 46Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial31 6.7.126
47Chouinard, Gerald Approve Technical34 6.7.11 48Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical34 6.7.11
49Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical36 6.8.1.111 50Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical39 6.8.1.2.59 51Ko, Gwangzeen Approve Editorial4161 52Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical44 6.8.1.3.1.79
53Ko, Gwangzeen Approve Editorial4561 54Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial47 6.91
55Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial49 6.9.1.14 56Chouinard, Gerald Approve Editorial53 6.9.319
57Ko, Gwangzeen Approve Editorial57624 58Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial57 6.9.4.124
59Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial64 6.9.7.319
60Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial65 6.9.7.3.27
61Riegel, Maximilian Disapprove Technical65 6.9.7.3.316 62Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical67 6.9.7.3.5.52
63Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical67 6.9.7.3.5.69 64Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical67 6.9.7.3.5.611
65Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Editorial69 6.9.7.3.5.103
66Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Editorial69 6.9.7.3.5.1212 67Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical74 6.9.8.9.42
68Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Editorial75 6.9.8.9.96
69Sasaki, Shigenobu Approve Editorial77 6.8.9.174 70Sasaki, Shigenobu Approve Editorial77 6.8.9.174
71Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Editorial78 6.9.8.9.17.49 72Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial78 6.9.8.9.1816
73Sasaki, Shigenobu Approve Editorial79 6.8.9.18.34
74Riegel, Maximilian Disapprove Technical79 6.9.8.9.18.111 75Sasaki, Shigenobu Approve Editorial79 6.8.9.18.315
76Sasaki, Shigenobu Approve Editorial79 6.8.9.18.215 77Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical83 6.9.8.1027
78Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical84 6.9.94 79Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial85 6.9.11.326
80Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial87 6.9.11.3.3.315 81Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical87 6.9.1221
82Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial95 6.9.18.1.17 83Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical97 6.9.18.1.1.58 84Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Editorial101 6.9.18.3.1.21
85Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical103 6.9.18.3.1.74
86Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial107 6.9.2112 87Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial114 6.10.223 88Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial117 6.10.4.1.21 89Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial127 6.11.6.22
90Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical131 6.12.2.15
91Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical131 6.12.2.233 92Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical131 6.12.2.344 93Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical132 6.12.2.47
94Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial133 6.13.225 95Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial139 6.158 96Ecclesine, Peter Disapprove General140 6.16.1.16
97Kennedy, Richard Disapprove Technical140 6.16.1.1.6
98Ecclesine, Peter Disapprove General140 6.16.1.17 99Kennedy, Richard Disapprove Technical140 6.16.1.17
100Freedman, Avraham Approve Technical142 6.16.27 101Freedman, Avraham Approve Technical142 6.16.27 102Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Editorial142 6.16.219 103Freedman, Avraham Approve Technical142 6.16.221
104Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial145 6.16.2.523 105Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical146 6.16.2.6.18
106Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial154 6.16.2.1020
107Chouinard, Gerald Approve Editorial154 6.16.2.1041 108Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial157 6.16.2.1237 109Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial163 6.17.11
110Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial164 6.17.2.140 111Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical169 6.19.25
112Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial170 6.19.220 113Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical170 6.19.331
114Chouinard, Gerald Approve Editorial191 6.20.9.3.34
115Sasaki, Shigenobu Approve Editorial191Figure 70
116Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial215 6.21.4.127 117Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial217 6.21.4.1.2.227
118Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial217 6.21.4.1.2.228 119A, Antony Franklin Approve Editorial221 6.2232
120Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial221 6.2232
121hu, wendong Disapprove Technical223 6.22.1.218 122hu, wendong Disapprove Technical223 6.22.1.218
123hu, wendong Disapprove Technical223 6.22.1.218 124hu, wendong Disapprove Technical231 6.22.3.24 125A, Antony Franklin Approve Editorial237 6.2342 126Karocki, Piotr Approve Editorial240 6.22
127Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial244 6.23.2.13 128A, Antony Franklin Approve Editorial244 6.23.2.115
129A, Antony Franklin Approve Editorial244 6.23.2.129 130A, Antony Franklin Approve Editorial248 6.24.115
131Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial248 6.24.234
132Diamond, Patrick Disapprove Technical249 6.25.110 133Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial25076
134Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial250717 135Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial250734
136Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical2507
137Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2527.1.221 138Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2527.1.341 139Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2537.2.110
140Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2537.2.111 141Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2547.2.14
142Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2597.2.2.710 143Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2607.2.2.71
144Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2617.2.3.122 145Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2617.2.3.131
146Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2617.2.3.240
147Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2637.2.3.21 148Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2647.2.3.2.19
149Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2657.2.3.2.28 150Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2657.2.3.2.322 151Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2677.2.3.2.523
152Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2687.2.3.2.511 153Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2687.2.3.2.515
154Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2687.2.437 155Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2697.2.4.521
156Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2697.2.4.6.1.132 157Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2697.2.4.6.1.135 158Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2697.2.4.6.1.235
159Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2697.2.4.6.1.144
160Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2707.2.52 161Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2727.2.66
162Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2727.2.724 163Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2737.2.8.143
164Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2757.3.1.116
165Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2757.3.1.235 166Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2797.3.23
167Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2797.3.2.16
168Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2797.3.2.17 169Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2807.43
170Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2807.4.134 171Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2807.4.136
172Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2817.4.2.1.133
173Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2837.4.2.1.41 174Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2837.4.2.1.45 175Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Editorial2857.4.317 176Struik, Rene Disapprove Editorial285723 177Struik, Rene Disapprove Editorial28672 178Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical28676
179Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical28678 180Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical286711
181Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical287723 182Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2887.5.1.4.224 183Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2887.5.1.4.342 184Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical290717 185Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial2927.626 186Tran, Ha Nguyen Approve General2937.6.1.322 187Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical294725 188Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical294728 189Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical29577
190Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical2957
191Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical29674 192Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical296718 193Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical2967.6.2.218
194Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical2967
195Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical2967
196Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical2967
197Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical2977
198Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical2977
199Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical298721 200Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical298725 201Struik, Rene Disapprove Technical2997
202Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial3007.6.2.5.36 203Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial3017.6.217 204Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical3027.6.33 205Chouinard, Gerald Approve Editorial3048.1.127
206Hwang, Sung Hyun Approve Editorial3078.27 207AMACHI, Nobumitsu Approve Editorial3158.323 208Hwang, Sung Hyun Approve Editorial3158.4.2.139
209Chouinard, Gerald Approve Technical3188.641
210Chouinard, Gerald Approve Editorial3228.6.422 211Chouinard, Gerald Approve Editorial3228.6.428
212Diamond, Patrick Disapprove Editorial3538.130 213Gurley, Thomas Disapprove Technical3558.12.27
214Chouinard, Gerald Approve Technical3558.12.27 215Kennedy, Richard Disapprove Technical35791
216Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical3599.2.234
217Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial3599.2.242 218Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical3629.2.3.111
219Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial3629.2.3.111 220hu, wendong Disapprove Technical3659.2.512
221Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical3699.2.51
222Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial3739.2.6.19 223Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical3749.2.6.215
224Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical3789.2.6.51 225Chouinard, Gerald Approve Editorial3859.3.252
226Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial3879.3.21 227Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical3899.3.38 228Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial3919.3.44
229Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial3919.3.412
230Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial3929.3.440 231Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical3959.3.58 232Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial3979.4.1.11 233Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical4009.4.1.119
234Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial4019.4.1.13
235Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial4029.4.1.3.121 236Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical4069.4.222
237Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical4079.4.222 238Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical4079.4.228
239Kennedy, Richard Disapprove Technical4089.52 240Methley, Steven Disapprove Technical4089.55 241Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical4089.5.125
242Freedman, Avraham Approve Editorial4099.5.2.121 243Freedman, Avraham Approve Technical4099.5.2.122
244Freedman, Avraham Approve Editorial4099.5.2.236 245Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial4099.5.2.236 246Reddy, Ranga Approve Editorial4099.5.2.237
247Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical4149.7.1.115
248A, Antony Franklin Approve Editorial4199.7.1.66 249Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Technical4279.7.4.217
250Gurley, Thomas Disapprove Technical4309.7.629 251Chouinard, Gerald Approve Technical4319.7.61
252Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical4541211 253Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical4541215 254Reddy, Ranga Approve Technical4541221
25 255Hwang, Sung Hyun Approve Technical46312.1.2.2.9,
12.1.2.2.10
256Chouinard, Gerald Approve Technical508 2.21 257Rahman, Mohammad Approve Technical523C1
258Rahman, Mohammad Approve Editorial524C1 259Chouinard, Gerald Approve Editorial525 C.1.11 260Mccann, Stephen Disapprove Editorial555 C.2.6.213
domain in which the devices are operated are mixed in with general
requirements: the standard fails to separate these requirements from the
general requirements. As additional regulatory domains define their
requirements for operation in the TVWS, this standard will require wholesale
rewrites to keep it viable.
Yes Considering the reference application to low population density regions, I object
to the characterization "a professional fixed base station", as the fixed base
station may be for educational or religious use.
No I don't understand the meaning of the word professional in the line
"...professional fixed base station"
Yes I think its necessary to define the word"professional" in the context of this specification. On one hand it could mean installation by a specialist company
charging fees, and on the other someone who is mearly competant to do this.
I'm concerned that the use of this word in an IEEE 802 standard is potentially
leading the market for such devises in a certain direction for certification
purposes, i.e. only certified products can be installed by a professional
company joe-bloggs who charges $xxxx.
No 1) The first sentence of the paragraph is a run-on sentnce and should be
broken up. 2) specifying a specific population density is not necessary, and
precludes deployments where sufficient channels are available to provide
service to (more) highly densely
Within Figure 2 there are two representations of WLAN technology, i.e. IEEE
Yes 802.11 and IEEE 802.11a. I think this is an outdated view of WLAN technology,
as IEEE 802.11y covers the 3.5 GHz band, whilst IEEE 802.11ad covers 60
GHz. I think a single mention of "IEEE 802.11" somewhere between the 2.4
and 5 GHz annuli will be more appropriate.
Yes The figure depicts "IEEE 802.11a", but after the 802.11REVma rollup to IEEE
Std 802.11-2007, the proper reference is to the clause 17 OFDM PHY of IEEE
802.11-2007. Needless to say, all versions of the 802.11 clause 17 OFDM PHY
have range greater than 33 meters. In the IEEE 802.11-2007 standard, a half-
clocked version is specified with twice the cyclic prefix, for use in 4.9 GHz
band, and subsequently by 802.11j, 802.11p and 802.11y approved
amendments to IEEE 802.11-2007. 802.11y-2008 added quarter-clocked 5
MHz version with four times the cyclic prefix protection that is also used by
802.11p-2009. IEEE 802.11n-2009 uses 40 MHz bandwidth as well as 20 MHz bandwidth in 2.4 GHz, and achieves datarates up to 600 Mbps. Check the
stores for 11n 3 x 2, 3 x 3 and 4 x 4 are coming this year.